The Cheese Store

Offering the freshest cheese curd and aged cheddar since 1974

-   ABOUT US  -


The Cheese Store is owned and operated by the Jefferson Bulk Milk Cooperative. The Jefferson Bulk Milk Cooperative currently consists of 23 local dairy farmers in Northern NY. The Jefferson Bulk Milk Cooperative has been in operation since 1964 and The Cheese Store has been open since 1974. Each dollar spent at The Cheese Store is returned to the local economy, supporting the farmers and workers who produce and manufacture most of our products! 

The Cheese Store is the very definition of LIVING LOCAL. We sell many local favorites such as Cheese Curd, Croghan Bologna, and Croghan Candy Kitchen sweets. We also sell essentials such as Black River Valley eggs, Upstate Farms milk and yogurt, Heidelberg bread, NYS produced maple syrup, honey and Great Lakes cheddar cheese.  We receive Cheese Curd twice each week so it is always SQUEEKY fresh!

All of our cheddar cheese is purchased locally in NYS and aged in-house in our walk-in cooler. Currently we have 565 - 40 pound blocks, or 11 TONS of cheese aging!

We ship anywhere in the USA with UPS 2 day shipping in an insulated cooler box. Place your order online or call us today at 315-788-1122 and we would be glad to make your TASTE OF NY dreams come true!